Step-by-step guide to getting approved for an auto loan with a repossession in your credit history, including subprime lenders and cosigner strategies

Having a repossession on your credit report doesn't mean you're permanently banned from getting another car loan. In fact, there's an entire industry of lenders who specialize in helping people with past credit problems, including repossessions. The key is knowing where to look, what lenders require, and how to position yourself for approval.

This comprehensive guide walks you through every step of getting an auto loan after repossession—from the best lenders to approach, to what documentation you need, to strategies for getting the best possible terms.

Understanding Your Position

Before you start applying, it's important to understand where you stand:

You're Now a Subprime Borrower

With a repo on your record, you're classified as "subprime" (credit score 580-669) or "deep subprime" (under 580), depending on your current score and how recent the repo was.

What this means:

• Higher interest rates than prime borrowers
• Stricter approval requirements
• Larger down payment expectations
• Shorter loan terms
• More documentation required

But You're Not Alone

Statistics:

• About 19-23% of auto loans go to subprime borrowers
• Millions of people with repos get approved every year
• The subprime auto lending market is worth over $150 billion annually

Lenders want your business—they just need to manage their risk appropriately.

Time Is Your Friend

The longer ago your repossession happened and the more you've rebuilt your credit, the easier approval becomes and the better your terms will be.

Timeline:

• 0-6 months: Very difficult, deep subprime only, terrible terms
• 6-12 months: Difficult, limited options, poor terms
• 12-24 months: Moderate difficulty, reasonable options, mediocre terms
• 24-36 months: Much easier, good options, acceptable terms
• 36+ months: Relatively easy if credit rebuilt, good terms available

For more details on what to expect, see our article on buying a car after repossession.

Where to Get Approved: Best Lender Types

Not all lenders handle repos the same way. Here's where you're most likely to get approved:

1. Subprime Auto Lenders (Best Option)

These lenders specialize in borrowers with challenged credit, including repossessions.

Major subprime lenders:

• Credit Acceptance Corporation: One of the largest, works with dealers nationwide
• Exeter Finance: Flexible with repos, reasonable rates for subprime
• Westlake Financial: Approves many repo situations
• Capital One Auto Finance (subprime division): Better terms than most subprime lenders
• Santander Consumer USA: Large subprime lender, extensive dealer network
• First Investors Financial Services: Specializes in deep subprime
• American Credit Acceptance: Works with recent repos

Pros:

• Specifically designed for your situation
• Higher approval rates
• Understand that past credit problems don't define you
• Work with most dealerships

Cons:

• Higher interest rates (typically 10-24%)
• May require significant down payment
• Shorter loan terms (36-60 months)

How to apply: These lenders typically work through dealerships. Visit a dealer and ask which subprime lenders they work with.

2. Credit Unions (Often Overlooked)

Credit unions are member-owned and often more flexible than traditional banks.

Why they're good:

• More willing to look at your whole story, not just your score
• Lower interest rates than subprime lenders
• Relationship-based lending (if you've banked with them, that helps)
• May consider explanation letters for repo
• Better customer service

Cons:

• Must be a member (usually easy to join)
• Not all credit unions do subprime lending
• May still deny if repo is very recent

Best credit unions for subprime:

• Pentagon Federal Credit Union (PenFed)
• Navy Federal Credit Union (military/family)
• Digital Federal Credit Union (DCU)
• Alliant Credit Union
• Local community credit unions

How to apply: Join the credit union (usually $5-$25 to open account), then apply for auto loan online or in person.

Pro Tip: If you've had an account with a credit union for 6+ months and maintained it well, they're much more likely to approve your auto loan despite the repo.

3. Online Subprime Lenders

Several online platforms specialize in connecting subprime borrowers with appropriate lenders.

Top online options:

• myAutoloan.com: Compares multiple lenders with one application
• Auto Credit Express: Specializes in bad credit auto loans
• Car.Loan.com: Works with subprime borrowers
• LendingTree Auto: Compares offers from multiple lenders
• RoadLoans (Santander): Direct online application for subprime

Pros:

• Apply from home
• Compare multiple offers at once
• Pre-qualification available (soft inquiry)
• Can see rates before going to dealership

Cons:

• May have fewer options for deep subprime (under 550 score)
• Rates might not be as competitive as credit unions
• Dealer might offer better deal in person

How to apply: Visit their websites, complete application, compare offers.

4. Manufacturer Captive Finance (Limited)

These are finance arms of car manufacturers (Ford Credit, Toyota Financial, Honda Financial, etc.).

Pros:

• Sometimes offer special subprime programs
• May have promotional rates or incentives
• Direct relationship with manufacturer

Cons:

• Much more selective with repos
• Typically won't approve if repo is recent (under 2-3 years)
• Usually require credit score of 600-620+ minimum

When it might work: If your repo is 3+ years old and you've rebuilt credit to 640+, you might qualify for manufacturer financing on a used car.

5. Buy-Here-Pay-Here (Last Resort Only)

What they are: Dealerships that provide their own financing without using banks or external lenders.

Pros:

• Will approve almost anyone with income
• No credit check (sometimes)
• Get a car same day

Cons:

• Extremely high interest (18-29%+)
• Cars often overpriced by 150-300%
• Aggressive collections and repossession
• Starter-interrupt devices
• Poor quality vehicles
• May not report positive payments to credit bureaus

When to consider: Only if:

• You've been denied everywhere else
• You absolutely need a car immediately for work
• You have no other option
• You understand you're paying a massive premium

Alternatives to explore first: Public transportation, rideshare, carpool, borrowing a car, renting, or waiting longer to improve approval odds elsewhere.

What Lenders Require

To maximize your approval chances, prepare these items before applying:

Documentation Checklist

Proof of Identity:

• Valid driver's license
• Social Security card or number

Proof of Income:

• Last 2-3 pay stubs (showing year-to-date earnings)
• If self-employed: last 2 years of tax returns and bank statements
• If on unemployment: benefit statement
• If receiving disability/SSI: award letter
• If multiple income sources: document all of them

Proof of Residence:

• Current utility bill (electric, gas, water)
• Lease or mortgage statement
• Bank statement with your address

Proof of Insurance:

• Quote showing you can get full coverage
• Some lenders require coverage before approval

Banking Information:

• Account and routing numbers for automatic payments
• Last 2 months of bank statements

References:

• 3-5 personal or professional references with phone numbers
• Some lenders check these

Down Payment Proof:

• Bank statement showing available funds
• Or physical check/cash on hand

Vehicle Information (if buying from private party):

• VIN, title, bill of sale

Down Payment Expectations

Down payment requirements vary by lender and how recent/severe your repo is:

Deep subprime (recent repo, under 550 score):

• 30-50% down required
• $5,000-$8,000 for a $15,000-$20,000 car

Subprime (6-24 months post-repo, 550-620 score):

• 20-30% down
• $3,000-$5,000 for a $15,000-$20,000 car

Near-prime (2+ years post-repo, 620-680 score):

• 10-20% down
• $1,500-$3,000 for a $15,000-$20,000 car

Why it matters:

• Reduces lender risk
• Shows you're financially stable
• Often gets you better interest rate
• Prevents being upside-down on loan

Income Requirements

Minimum monthly income: Most lenders want to see $1,500-$2,500/month minimum gross income

Debt-to-income ratio: Lenders prefer your total monthly debt payments (including the new car payment) to be under 45-50% of your gross monthly income

Example:

• Gross monthly income: $3,000
• Maximum acceptable debt: $1,500/month
• Current debts: $500/month (credit cards, student loans, etc.)
• Maximum car payment you can qualify for: ~$1,000/month

Employment stability: Most lenders want:

• Same employer for 6-12+ months
• No gaps in employment
• Consistent income (not fluctuating wildly month to month)

Step-by-Step Application Process

Follow this process to maximize your approval odds:

Step 1: Check and Understand Your Credit

Get all three credit reports:

• Visit AnnualCreditReport.com
• Review Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion reports
• Look for errors and dispute them

Know your scores:

• Check FICO scores (most lenders use FICO, not VantageScore)
• Credit Karma shows VantageScore (useful but not what lenders use)
• Experian app shows FICO score for free

Understand what lenders will see:

• When the repo occurred
• Current balance/deficiency (if any)
• Recent payment history on all accounts
• Current credit utilization
• Any other negative marks

For strategies to improve your score, see our guide on rebuilding credit after repossession.

Step 2: Address Any Outstanding Issues

Deficiency balance:

• If you owe a deficiency from the repo, try to pay it off or settle it before applying
• If you can't, at least document that you have a payment plan
• Some lenders won't approve with unpaid deficiency; others don't care

Other collections or late payments:

• Bring all accounts current if possible
• Document any payment plans you're on

Errors on credit report:

• Dispute and resolve before applying
• Don't let fixable errors prevent approval

For help with deficiencies, read our article on dealing with deficiency debt.

Step 3: Save Your Down Payment

Based on your situation, save:

• Recent repo (under 12 months): Target 30-40% of car price
• Older repo (12-24 months): Target 20-25%
• Old repo (24+ months) with rebuilt credit: Target 15-20%

Where to save:

• Dedicated savings account
• Cashier's check
• Money order

Never: Pay down payment with credit card cash advance or payday loan.

Step 4: Get Pre-Qualified or Pre-Approved

Pre-qualification (soft inquiry, doesn't affect credit):

• Visit online lenders like myAutoloan, Capital One Auto Navigator, LendingTree
• See what you might qualify for
• No commitment, just information

Pre-approval (hard inquiry, affects credit slightly):

• Apply with 2-3 lenders within a 14-day window (counts as one inquiry)
• Get actual approval with specific rate and terms
• Brings approved amount to dealership

Benefits:

• Know your budget before shopping
• Avoid dealer markup
• Negotiate from position of strength
• Saves time

Step 5: Shop for the Right Car

Lender-friendly characteristics:

• 2-7 years old (not brand new, not ancient)
• Under 75,000 miles (preferably under 60,000)
• Reliable brands: Honda, Toyota, Ford, Chevrolet, Nissan, Hyundai, Kia
• Reasonable price: $10,000-$20,000 range
• Clean title (not salvage)

What to avoid:

• Luxury brands (lenders often decline)
• High-mileage vehicles (over 100K)
• Cars older than 10 years
• Salvage or rebuilt titles
• Expensive new cars

Where to shop:

• Certified pre-owned from franchised dealers
• Reputable used car dealers
• Private sellers (if your lender allows)

Step 6: Apply With Multiple Lenders

Don't just apply to one place. Apply to:

1. Your local credit union (if you're a member)
2. 1-2 online lenders (myAutoloan, Auto Credit Express)
3. Dealership finance department (they work with multiple lenders)

Timeline: Submit all applications within 14 days so they count as one inquiry on your credit report.

Compare offers based on:

• APR (interest rate)
• Monthly payment
• Total interest paid over life of loan
• Loan term
• Fees
• Prepayment penalties (avoid if possible)

Step 7: Negotiate the Best Terms

Once approved, you may be able to negotiate:

Larger down payment for lower APR: "I can put down $5,000 instead of $3,000. Can you reduce my APR from 16% to 14%?"

Shorter term for lower rate: "If I do a 48-month term instead of 60, can you lower the rate?"

Don't just focus on monthly payment: Dealers love to extend terms to lower monthly payment, but you pay way more interest. Focus on APR and total cost.

Get everything in writing: Verbal promises mean nothing.

Step 8: Review All Documents Carefully

Before signing:

Read every page:

• Purchase agreement
• Finance contract
• Insurance requirements
• Warranty information
• Any add-ons

Verify:

• ✅ APR matches what you were quoted
• ✅ Loan term is correct
• ✅ Monthly payment is accurate
• ✅ Down payment is credited correctly
• ✅ No unexpected fees or add-ons
• ✅ No pre-payment penalties
• ✅ Total amount financed is correct

Watch out for:

• ❌ Spot delivery (you take the car home but financing isn't final—avoid this)
• ❌ Dealer add-ons you didn't agree to (VIN etching, paint protection, extended warranties)
• ❌ Yo-yo financing (dealer calls you back days later saying financing fell through and demands more money)

Don't be pressured: If something doesn't match what you agreed to, don't sign. Walk away if necessary.

Strategies to Get Better Terms

Even with a repo, you can improve your approval terms:

Strategy 1: Use a Cosigner

If you have a trusted friend or family member with good credit (680+), they can cosign.

Benefits:

• Dramatically better approval odds
• Much lower interest rate (potentially save 5-10%+)
• Lower down payment requirement

Requirements for cosigner:

• Good credit (usually 680+)
• Stable income
• Low debt-to-income ratio
• Willing to be fully responsible if you don't pay

Risks:

• If you miss payments, it destroys their credit too
• They're legally liable for the full loan
• Can ruin your relationship

When to consider: Only if you're absolutely certain you can and will make every payment, and they fully understand the risk.

Strategy 2: Wait Longer and Rebuild More

Every additional month you wait (while rebuilding credit) can save you thousands:

Example:

• $15,000 car, 60-month loan
• At 6 months post-repo with 560 score: 20% APR = $396/month, $8,760 interest
• At 18 months post-repo with 620 score: 12% APR = $334/month, $5,040 interest
• Savings by waiting 12 more months: $3,720

Use the waiting time to:

• Save a larger down payment
• Build perfect payment history on secured credit card
• Complete a credit-builder loan
• Bring credit score up 40-60 points

Strategy 3: Consider a Less Expensive Car

Lenders are more likely to approve a $12,000 loan than a $22,000 loan.

Benefits:

• Higher approval odds
• Better terms
• Lower payment
• Less risk if you face hardship again
• Easier to refinance later

You can upgrade in 12-18 months once you've established good payment history.

Strategy 4: Build Relationship With a Credit Union

3-6 months before applying for car loan:

• Join a local credit union
• Open checking and savings accounts
• Set up direct deposit
• Use their services regularly
• Apply for secured credit card if they offer one

When you apply for car loan: You're an established member, not a stranger. This significantly improves approval odds and terms.

Strategy 5: Get a Guarantor Instead of Cosigner

Some lenders offer a "guarantor" option:

• Guarantor is only responsible if you completely default
• Less risky for the guarantor than cosigning
• Still improves your approval odds
• Not all lenders offer this—ask

Strategy 6: Make a Huge Down Payment

If you can put down 40-50%, you might get dramatically better terms even with a recent repo:

Why it works:

• Lender risk is minimal
• Shows financial discipline
• Equity from day one
• Can sometimes get near-prime rates even with subprime credit

Example:

• $15,000 car with $7,500 down (50%)
• Loan amount: only $7,500
• Easier to approve, better rate, lower payment

Common Mistakes That Lead to Denial

Avoid these pitfalls:

Mistake 1: Applying Too Soon

Applying immediately after repo with no credit rebuilding efforts leads to:

• Denials from most lenders
• Hard inquiries that further hurt your score
• Desperation that leads to predatory lenders

Better: Wait at least 3-6 months while rebuilding.

Mistake 2: Lying on Applications

Never lie about:

• Income
• Employment
• Residence
• Other debts

Why: Lenders verify everything. Getting caught lying means:

• Automatic denial
• Possible fraud charges
• Blacklisted from that lender forever

Mistake 3: Applying to Too Many Lenders Outside the Window

Hard inquiries hurt your score. Applying to 10 lenders over 3 months drops your score significantly.

Better: Research first, then apply to 3-4 lenders within a 14-day window.

Mistake 4: Forgetting About Insurance

Subprime borrowers often face higher insurance rates. Factor this into your budget.

Before applying: Get insurance quotes for the type of car you're considering. Make sure you can afford payment + insurance.

Mistake 5: Accepting First Offer

The first lender to approve you may not offer the best terms.

Better: Apply to multiple lenders, compare all offers, negotiate.

Mistake 6: Focusing Only on Monthly Payment

Dealers will extend loan terms to make monthly payment sound attractive:

"We can get you in this car for only $299/month!"

Reality: It's a 72-month loan at 20% APR where you pay $21,528 for a $15,000 car.

Better: Focus on APR and total cost, not just monthly payment.

After Approval: Protecting Your Investment

Once approved:

Make Every Payment On Time

Set up autopay for at least a few days before due date.

Build an emergency fund for car repairs and unexpected expenses.

Communicate with lender if you foresee any difficulty—they may work with you if you've been responsible.

For prevention strategies, see our article on auto loan hardship programs.

Plan to Refinance

After 12-18 months of on-time payments, your credit will improve significantly.

Refinance to:

• Lower interest rate (potentially save $2,000-$5,000)
• Reduce monthly payment
• Remove cosigner (if applicable)

When to refinance: When your credit score has improved by 40-60+ points and you have 12+ months of perfect payment history.

Build Credit With the Loan

Your auto loan is a major opportunity to rebuild credit:

• Shows installment loan payment history
• Improves credit mix
• Demonstrates responsibility

After 2-3 years of perfect auto loan payments, your credit score can recover to 680-720+ even with the old repo still on your report.

Your Action Plan

This week:

1. Check all three credit reports
2. Dispute any errors
3. Calculate realistic budget
4. Start saving down payment

Next 30 days:

1. Apply for secured credit card
2. Continue saving
3. Address any outstanding deficiencies or collections
4. Research lenders and vehicles

At 3-6 months (if you need a car sooner):

1. Get pre-qualified with online lenders
2. Apply to credit union
3. Visit dealerships with strong subprime programs
4. Compare offers and negotiate
5. Buy reliable, affordable vehicle

At 12+ months (ideal timeline):

1. Apply with broader range of lenders
2. Expect much better terms
3. Larger selection of vehicles
4. Better negotiating position

After purchase:

1. Make every payment on time
2. Maintain full coverage insurance
3. Budget for maintenance
4. Plan to refinance in 12-18 months

---

Free Tools to Help You Keep Your Car

• Repo Countdown Tool – Understand your timeline if you're at risk again
• Hardship Letter Generator – Request help if you face future difficulties
• Debt Relief Quiz – Get personalized financial recommendations

---